• HC Visitor
Skip to content
Getting Deeper Into Dett
Getting Deeper Into Dett

Thoughts on States of Research

Ann Key Simpson

Sources Collide: Dett at Harvard Part III, Why This Actually Tells Us Something Useful

2023-02-17
By: Jeannie Ma. Guerrero, PhD
On: February 17, 2023
In: Biography, LegendChecker, Sources Collide
Tagged: Ann Key Simpson, Harvard, Lori Rae Shipley

If I have failed to illustrate the confusion afforded by the source situation for a single year of Dett’s life, well, please be my guest and write Dett’s biography because I do not believe I can fix this by myself. As I understand it, Simpson thinks Dett took one group of courses, while Shipley thinks he took a different group of courses. Both Simpson and Shipley use materials from the Hampton Archives almost exclusively. While they present different conclusions on the details, both Simpson and Shipley agree that Dett’s supervisors (Davison, Gregg, Peabody) did not know what Dett was actually doing. I believe that DettRead More →

Sources Collide: Dett at Harvard Part II, Shipley’s Reckoning

2023-02-16
By: Jeannie Ma. Guerrero, PhD
On: February 16, 2023
In: Biography, LegendChecker, Sources Collide
Tagged: Ann Key Simpson, Harvard, Lori Rae Shipley

Lori Rae Shipley’s dissertation, A History of the Music Department at Hampton Institute/University, 1868-1972, has a wider focus than Simpson’s biography of Dett. Because of her broader scope, Shipley examines administrative documents from Hampton that are not included in Simpson’s work. Thus, we receive a fuller picture of how Dett’s Harvard sabbatical arose. Archibald Davison, who is reported to have invited Dett to Harvard, initially became acquainted with Dett through Davison’s role as a “visiting music consultant” per Hampton’s 1920 President Annual Report [p. 138]. In essence, Davison was brought to Hampton as part of a Visiting Committee, which is usually used to review anRead More →

Sources Collide: Dett at Harvard Part I, Simpson’s List of Courses

2023-02-15
By: Jeannie Ma. Guerrero, PhD
On: February 15, 2023
In: Biography, LegendChecker, MetaPosts, Sources Collide
Tagged: Ann Key Simpson, Harvard

In a previous post, I (outrageously) argued that Dett’s time at Harvard University was not spent in the way that current research presents it, namely, that he took coursework with Archibald Davison. In that post, I showed the courses that Archibald Davison taught on the (Harvard) record, which means that it probably happened that way because, hey, that’s how Harvard rolls. I would like to present how Ann Key Simpson reports Dett’s Harvard year, because her reckoning lies at the heart of a crucial research issue for Dett (and likely others from this time period): sources collide and spawn most of the difficulties with whichRead More →

Copyright © 2023 Jeannie Ma. Guerrero, PhD. Information subject to change

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Why I Blog: Historical Erasure Still Happens March 1, 2023
  • The Surviving Detts Leave Rochester February 27, 2023
  • Harvard (Segregated) Housing February 18, 2023
  • Sources Collide: Dett at Harvard Part III, Why This Actually Tells Us Something Useful February 17, 2023
  • Sources Collide: Dett at Harvard Part II, Shipley’s Reckoning February 16, 2023
  • Sources Collide: Dett at Harvard Part I, Simpson’s List of Courses February 15, 2023
  • LegendChecker: Dett did not enroll at the Conservatoire Américain de Fontainebleau February 14, 2023
  • Dett the Rochesterian: Cursory Introduction February 13, 2023
  • When Dett Composed The Ordering of Moses February 12, 2023
  • LegendChecker: Dett Did Not Study with Arthur Foote AT Harvard February 12, 2023

Post Archive

  • March 2023 (1)
  • February 2023 (13)

Tags

Ann Key Simpson Fontainebleau Harvard Lori Rae Shipley Ordering of Moses Rochester

Copyright © 2023 Jeannie Ma. Guerrero, PhD. Information subject to change.

This site is part of Knowledge Commons. Explore other sites on this network or register to build your own.
Terms of ServicePrivacy PolicyGuidelines for Participation